How to find a good business advisor (and why it's the fastest way to scale)
Most business owners learn how to scale the slow way, by trial and error over a decade or more. This article explains what separates a real business advisor from a consultant, coach or mentor, and how the right one can turn years of mistakes into months of progress.

Most business owners learn how to scale their business the hard way, working things out by trial and error, one mistake at a time. The problem with this is it's the slowest route there is and it can be expensive. The most successful business owners I've known weren't necessarily the smarest or even the hardest working people. What set them apart is that every time they hit a wall, they found someone who had already walked the path they were on and had the humility to ask for help, the discipline to listen, and, most importantly, the follow-through to act on what they heard.
The best news is that if you run your own business you don't have to spend years working things out alone. The right business advisor can change the direction of your business, and your life, faster than anything else you can buy. The problem is that most people only have a vague idea of what a business advisor is and they have no way of knowing how to find a good one who will actually help them in their business.
If this resonates with you, read my article about what a good business advisor looks like, the difference between a business advisor, a coach and a mentor and what you need to bring to the relationship in order to get the most out of it.
What a good business advisor looks like
A good business advisor stays with you for the long haul and holds you accountable to your goals and decisions and business plan. They bring experience from working with many businesses, so they can spot problems early. Unlike a consultant, they don't hand over a report and leave. They meet with you regularly, track your numbers, follow up on what you committed to, and share responsibility for the results.
That's a different relationship from most of what gets sold as business advice. A consultant is usually brought in to solve a defined problem and then moves on. A coach helps you find your own answers by asking good questions. Both have their place. A business advisor stays with you over time, hands you the map they drew themselves, mistakes and all, and shares responsibility for what happens next.
The difference is most apparent when things get hard. Someone working from a framework can only guess at what might work, whereas a business advisor who has been there already knows what worked and what didn't.
Business advisor or mentor: what's the difference?
People often use the terms "mentor" and "business advisor" as if they mean the same thing. They overlap, but the difference matters when you're deciding who to ask for help.
A mentor is usually an informal relationship. They share what they've learned from their own career, often without charge and when they have time. Their advice can be invaluable, but nobody is accountable for whether it works, and the relationship runs on goodwill rather than structure. In essence, a mentor is someone who has already achieved what you're trying to achieve, namely, success in a certain industry. The problem with only working with a mentor is that they may not be able to reverse engineer why they were so successful and the lack of structure to a mentor-mentee relationship can be problematic for lots of business founders who need the discipline of goal setting and accountability regarding implementation.
A business advisor brings a structure designed to produce results: regular meetings with a clear agenda, agreed actions, your numbers tracked month to month, and shared responsibility for the outcome. A good advisor draws on patterns they've seen across many businesses.
Early in my career, what I had was a mentor. What made it work was that we treated the engagement like advisory. I brought an agenda, my KPIs and the problems I needed help with to every meeting, and I was expected to act on what we discussed. That combination, a mentor's experience with an advisor's discipline, is what speeds up growth. When you look for help, don't settle for experience without structure, or structure without experience.
How the right advisor can compress a decade into a single year
A good business advisor can be motivating when you need it, but that isn't where most of the value comes from. The real value is practical.
Someone who has built what you're building has seen your problem many times before, across many different businesses. They can usually spot it in minutes, when you might otherwise spend months or years finding the answer the hard way. That pattern recognition is worth more than formal education because it comes from seeing the same situation again and again, not from theory.
A good business advisor will also tell you the uncomfortable things nobody else around you will say. Early on, my own mentor told me: "I can't change your firm unless I change you first." An employee, a peer or a friend is unlikely to say that to your face. It takes the standing to say it credibly and the willingness to risk the relationship. A business advisor who has built what you want to build has earned that standing, and a good one will use it.
How to get the most out of a business advisor
Charlie Munger, one of my heroes, put it simply: "To get what you want, you have to deserve what you want." The same applies here. An advisor can only take you as far as the work you're willing to do between meetings.
You need three things to get the most out of a good business advisor:
1. You need to come prepared
Arrive at every meeting with a clear agenda. In the three years I worked with my mentor, I always brought a list of questions, the issues in my firm I needed help with, and my year-to-date KPIs so we could track how the business was going. A good advisor will expect the same from you.
2. You need to stay humble
Be honest about what's going wrong, not just the story that makes you look good. A good business advisor can only help with the problems you tell them about. Some debate is healthy, especially while you're getting used to new ways of thinking about your business, but if you're constantly pushing back on the advice, either you've picked the wrong advisor or your ego is getting in the way.
3. You need to take action
I've worked with more than 50 SMEs. The ones that made the most progress had one thing in common: they put into practice what we agreed in our monthly board meetings. Nodding along and then carrying on the old way changes nothing and wastes everyone's time.
How to find the right business advisor
Start by getting specific about what you want. "More success" is too vague. Name the outcome whether it be a business of a certain size, a certain kind of freedom, or a particular transition you're trying to make. Then look for someone who has built that outcome, for themselves and for others, rather than someone who just talks about it well. You'll quickly see the difference once you start asking detailed questions about how they did it.
Then ask how they structure the relationship: how often you'll meet, what gets tracked, and what they'll hold you to between meetings. If the answer is "we'll catch up when we can", you've found a mentor. That's valuable, but it isn't the same thing.
Reading helps too. It won't replace the value that comes from enganging a business advisor, but it will teach you what a good one looks like. A great place to start is Trillion Dollar Coach, about Bill Campbell, the coach behind Steve Jobs, Eric Schmidt and many of Silicon Valley's best-known leaders. Campbell was called a coach, but he worked the way the best advisors do: closely, over many years, and willing to tell people what they didn't want to hear. It's a short book, and a good picture of what that kind of relationship looks like in practice.
We work with business owners to build the leadership, systems and teams they need to scale, so the business runs on more than just the founder's time and effort. Book a conversation to find out where to start.
FAQ
